A Rare Center Grove Estate: 3935 W Smokey Row Road, Bargersville, Indiana
Some homes are simply in a category of their own. 3935 W Smokey Row Road in Bargersville, Indiana is exactly that. Listed in the heart of Center Grove, this exceptional Mike Duke-built estate sits on 3.68 beautifully landscaped acres on a corner lot — surrounded by mature trees, overlooking a picturesque pond with a lighted aerator and fountain, and offering the kind of park-like setting that is nearly impossible to find in one of Central Indiana's most sought-after communities. With an in-ground pool, a custom-built boat dock with all-new wood flooring, a freshly painted gazebo, and a separate heated and cooled Carriage House, this is more than a home — it's a private retreat.
Inside, the home delivers 4 bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, and 2 half baths across a thoughtfully designed floor plan that balances elegance with everyday livability. Beautiful beveled White Oak hardwood flooring flows throughout, complemented by Amish-crafted kitchen cabinetry that adds warmth and craftsmanship to the heart of the home. A private office with double glass doors and leaded-glass transoms adds architectural character, while the primary bath stuns with a dramatic 12-foot ceiling and an illuminated display ledge wrapping the upper portion of the room. The finished basement features daylight windows, a bar area, and a theatre space — everything you need to entertain in style without ever leaving home.
The outdoor and auxiliary spaces are equally impressive. Six total garage bays include a 3-bay attached garage with a convenient half bath perfectly positioned for pool access, and a separate 3-bay Carriage House offering approximately 1,100 square feet of finished space — complete with a full bathroom, utility room, laundry sink, upstairs family room, and bedroom area ideal for guests, a home office, or additional living. A beautiful 12' x 26' covered porch along the south side of the Carriage House provides a shaded setting to take in the stunning property. Both garages feature epoxy flooring with UV protection — a finishing touch that speaks to the quality and care that defines every inch of this estate.
Center Grove is one of Johnson County's most prestigious addresses — known for its top-ranked Center Grove Community School Corporation, convenient access to I-69, and a community feel that draws families from across Central Indiana and beyond. At 3.68 acres with a pond, pool, Carriage House, and a Mike Duke build behind it, this property offers a level of privacy, versatility, and craftsmanship that is exceptionally rare in today's market.
This remarkable listing is brought to you by Amanda Cottingham Johnson with CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Amanda brings deep local expertise and a genuine commitment to her clients to every transaction she touches. Connect with Amanda today or reach her directly at 317-201-7753. And when you're ready to talk financing, our partners at Milestone Home Lending are here to make the process smooth and stress-free from start to finish.
Estates like this rarely come to market. Don't wait to schedule your private showing.
