Amanda Cottingham Johnson

Amanda Johnson is the founder of Amanda Johnson Property Group and a trusted real estate professional serving Central Indiana with over two decades of experience. 

With a background as a licensed residential appraiser, Amanda offers her clients a distinct advantage when it comes to pricing strategy, market analysis, and protecting property value. Over the past 10 years, she has also been actively involved in property development throughout the Center Grove and surrounding areas, [...]

Amanda Johnson is the founder of Amanda Johnson Property Group and a trusted real estate professional serving Central Indiana with over two decades of experience. 

With a background as a licensed residential appraiser, Amanda offers her clients a distinct advantage when it comes to pricing strategy, market analysis, and protecting property value. Over the past 10 years, she has also been actively involved in property development throughout the Center Grove and surrounding areas, giving her a deep understanding of land use, construction, and investment potential.

Amanda specializes in working with first-time homebuyers, luxury and high-end properties, farms and land, and new construction. Her approach combines data-driven insights with strong negotiation skills and a hands-on, client-first mindset.

She is an active member of the Southside MIBOR and stays ahead of market trends, including shifting interest rates, inventory challenges, and new construction opportunities—ensuring her clients are always positioned to make confident, informed decisions.

In addition to real estate, Amanda owns and operates several successful local businesses, including Bay Horse Inn, a premier wedding and event venue, The Stables of Bay Horse Inn, a horse boarding facility, and Johnson’s Hauling & Excavating, a company specializing in commercial and residential site work. These ventures provide her with a unique, full-scope understanding of property—from raw land to finished homes.

Deeply rooted in the community, Amanda has supported multiple local nonprofits and believes in giving back to the area she calls home.

Whether you’re buying, selling, building, or investing, Amanda Johnson offers unmatched experience, local knowledge, and a commitment to excellence every step of the way.